• Home
  • Current Issue
  • Category Search
    • Arbitration
    • DLI Hearings Bureau
    • Federal Trial Courts
    • Justice Courts
    • Ninth Circuit Court
    • State Trial Courts
    • Supreme Court – Civil
    • Supreme Court – Criminal
    • US Supreme Court
    • Bankruptcy Court
    • Workers’ Compensation Court
    • Board of Personnel Appeals
    • Human Rights
  • Indexes
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index – 2025
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index – 2024
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2023
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2022
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2021
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2020
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2019
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2018
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2017
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2016
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2015
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2014
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2013
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2012
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2011
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index – 2010
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2009
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index – 2008
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2007
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2006
  • Subscribe

Montana Law Week

The Weekly Digest of Montana Law

Robbery/kidnap/drugs, pharmacy holdup

February 7, 2026 By lilly

ROBBERY/KIDNAP/DRUGS: Pharmacy robbery convictions affirmed over challenges to hearing impaired witness, sufficiency of evidence, use of overlay of store and pawn shop security footage during closing… Allison affirmed. [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Supreme Court – Criminal Tagged With: Gregory Birdsong, John Donovan, Mardell Ployhar

Sentencing, credit for recovery center time

July 5, 2025 By lilly

SENTENCING: Defendant not entitled to credit for time at recovery center which he chose to attend without court order… Wilson affirmed. [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Supreme Court – Criminal Tagged With: Christine Hutchison, John Donovan, Joshua Thornton

Jury, failure to certify non-responders

March 29, 2025 By lilly

JURY: Clerk’s failure to certify to the Sheriff jurors who did not return their questionnaires did not rise to substantial noncompliance… conviction of murder of wife affirmed… Allison affirmed. [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Supreme Court – Criminal Tagged With: Jeff Wilson, John Donovan, Mardell Ployhar

Probationary search, door opened a “crack,” meth

October 21, 2023 By lilly

PROBATIONARY SEARCH: Home visit properly evolved into search that yielded meth after PO entered exterior structure, knocked repeatedly on trailer door, opened door a “crack,” called for probationer, she let officers in, and officer observed meth pipe in plain view… motion to suppress properly denied… Allison affirmed. [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Supreme Court – Criminal Tagged With: Bjorn Boyer, John Donovan, Karl Pitcher

Deliberate homicide, failure to call “alibi witnesses”

October 14, 2023 By lilly

DELIBERATE HOMICIDE: Defendant not prejudiced by attorney’s failure to call purported alibi witnesses, ineffective assistance claim properly denied without a hearing… Allison affirmed. [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Supreme Court – Criminal Tagged With: John Donovan, Nick Brooke, Tammy Plubell

DUI, Prosecutor as impeachment witness

July 9, 2022 By lilly

DUI: Felony conviction affirmed over challenge to refusal to allow Defendant to call Prosecutor to impeach a witness with asserted inconsistent interview statements as to witness’s drinking… remanded to clarify parole conditions as recommendations and strike provision for supervision fees… Allison affirmed, reversed (memorandum). [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Supreme Court – Criminal Tagged With: Bree Gee, Deborah Smith, John Donovan

Drugs, hotel room door kick-in

May 16, 2020 By lilly

DRUGS: Exigent circumstances supported kicking in suspected dealer’s hotel room door… Wilson affirmed. [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Supreme Court – Criminal Tagged With: Deborah Smith, John Donovan, Lindsey Simon

Revocation, home visit search, return to MSP v. DOC

February 22, 2020 By lilly

REVOCATION: Violation of at least one probation condition sufficient to revoke irrespective of what allegedly illegal home visit search uncovered… return to MSP more burdensome than 2001 DOC commitment under 1997 statute, remanded to reflect DOC commitment… Allison affirmed, reversed (IOR I-3(c)). [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Supreme Court – Criminal Tagged With: Gregory Hood, John Donovan, Tammy Plubell

Deliberate homicide, evidence of abuse of wife

January 18, 2020 By lilly

DELIBERATE HOMICIDE: Defendant’s lawyer may have had good reason not to object to evidence of abuse of wife but in any event no prejudice as evidence was overwhelming that he threw victim off bridge as opposed to victim falling… Wilson affirmed (IOR I-3(c)). [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Supreme Court – Criminal Tagged With: Danny Tenenbaum, John Donovan, Tammy Plubell

Sexual assault, revocation, sex treatment conditions

November 30, 2019 By lilly

SEXUAL ASSAULT: Sufficient evidence that Defendant violated sex treatment condition of release, revocation affirmed… Allison affirmed (IOR I-3(c)). [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Supreme Court – Criminal Tagged With: Anna Saverud, John Donovan, William Hooks

  • 1
  • 2
  • Next Page »

Login Status

Search This Website

Archives

  • ►2026
    • ▼February (11)
      • Holographic will valid only for appointing PR
      • Marital, failure to file disclosures
      • Initiative, CI-132's ballot statement
      • Attorney discipline, Joshua Van de Wetering suspended
      • Rape, "regrettable sex defense," blind experts
      • Attempted deliberate homicide by vehicle, jail call
      • Robbery/kidnap/drugs, pharmacy holdup
      • $13,461.17 verdict, pit bull bite of child
      • Defense verdict, home defects, soils/foundation system
      • Defense verdict, discharge of reclaimed irrigation water
      • $475,000 settlement, jail suicide
    • ►January (57)
  • ►2025
    • ►August (48)
    • ►July (40)
    • ►June (30)
    • ►May (42)
    • ►April (27)
    • ►March (43)
    • ►February (35)
    • ►January (32)
  • ►2024
    • ►December (41)
    • ►November (36)
    • ►October (24)
    • ►September (38)
    • ►August (44)
    • ►July (34)
    • ►June (47)
    • ►May (36)
    • ►April (33)
    • ►March (44)
    • ►February (32)
    • ►January (35)
  • ►2023
    • ►December (35)
    • ►November (35)
    • ►October (28)
    • ►September (36)
    • ►August (27)
    • ►July (40)
    • ►June (38)
    • ►May (40)
    • ►April (26)
    • ►March (29)
    • ►February (28)
    • ►January (23)
  • ►2022
    • ►December (39)
    • ►November (36)
    • ►October (41)
    • ►September (20)
    • ►August (30)
    • ►July (40)
    • ►June (28)
    • ►May (27)
    • ►April (28)
    • ►March (34)
    • ►February (31)
    • ►January (52)
  • ►2021
    • ►December (37)
    • ►November (37)
    • ►October (48)
    • ►September (37)
    • ►August (49)
    • ►July (43)
    • ►June (30)
    • ►May (52)
    • ►April (46)
    • ►March (39)
    • ►February (40)
    • ►January (16)
  • ►2020
    • ►December (36)
    • ►November (41)
    • ►October (43)
    • ►September (37)
    • ►August (46)
    • ►July (37)
    • ►June (41)
    • ►May (57)
    • ►April (39)
    • ►March (33)
    • ►February (41)
    • ►January (34)
  • ►2019
    • ►December (28)
    • ►November (43)
    • ►October (22)
    • ►September (42)
    • ►August (45)
    • ►July (31)
    • ►June (44)
    • ►May (37)
    • ►April (36)
    • ►March (46)
    • ►February (41)
    • ►January (30)
  • ►2018
    • ►December (52)
    • ►November (38)
    • ►October (30)
    • ►September (48)
    • ►August (38)
    • ►July (36)
    • ►June (48)
    • ►May (43)
    • ►April (48)
    • ►March (55)
    • ►February (44)
    • ►January (46)
  • ►2017
    • ►December (46)
    • ►November (42)
    • ►October (37)
    • ►September (51)
    • ►August (35)
    • ►July (56)
    • ►June (51)
    • ►May (49)
    • ►April (59)
    • ►March (39)
    • ►February (39)
    • ►January (41)
  • ►2016
    • ►December (51)
    • ►November (44)
    • ►October (53)
    • ►September (39)
    • ►August (36)
    • ►July (55)
    • ►June (38)
    • ►May (37)
    • ►April (55)
    • ►March (37)
    • ►February (29)
    • ►January (51)
  • ►2015
    • ►December (34)
    • ►November (33)
    • ►October (59)
    • ►September (43)
    • ►August (46)
    • ►July (44)
    • ►June (54)
    • ►May (58)
    • ►April (53)
    • ►March (43)
    • ►February (41)
    • ►January (47)
  • ►2014
    • ►December (45)
    • ►November (45)
    • ►October (42)
    • ►September (43)
    • ►August (56)
    • ►July (43)
    • ►June (54)
    • ►May (56)
    • ►April (57)
    • ►March (56)
    • ►February (48)
    • ►January (38)
  • ►2013
    • ►December (40)
    • ►November (52)
    • ►October (38)
    • ►September (46)
    • ►August (63)
    • ►July (47)
    • ►June (73)
    • ►May (43)
    • ►April (47)
    • ►March (69)
    • ►February (41)
    • ►January (36)
  • ►2012
    • ►December (49)
    • ►November (39)
    • ►October (46)
    • ►September (53)
    • ►August (51)
    • ►July (42)
    • ►June (52)
    • ►May (48)
    • ►April (44)
    • ►March (47)
    • ►February (37)
    • ►January (52)
  • ►2011
    • ►December (73)
    • ►November (71)
    • ►October (51)
    • ►September (35)
    • ►August (42)
    • ►July (62)
    • ►June (51)
    • ►May (38)
    • ►April (61)
    • ►March (44)
    • ►February (55)
    • ►January (64)
  • ►2010
    • ►December (45)
    • ►November (51)
    • ►October (65)
    • ►September (52)
    • ►August (37)
    • ►July (70)
    • ►June (45)
    • ►May (61)
    • ►April (52)
    • ►March (66)
    • ►February (51)
    • ►January (62)
  • ►2009
    • ►September (55)
    • ►August (60)
    • ►July (51)
    • ►June (32)
    • ►May (87)
    • ►April (56)
    • ►March (57)
    • ►February (55)
    • ►January (62)

Archives Dropdown

© Copyright 2026 Montana Law Week. All Rights Reserved.

Website, hosting, and design provided by