Plan I
George Fuller, lungs, 11/11, disputed, $79,900, Michael Bliven
Jay Baumberger, low back, 2/10, $47,500, Stacy Tempel-St. John [Read more…]
The Weekly Digest of Montana Law
By lilly
Plan I
George Fuller, lungs, 11/11, disputed, $79,900, Michael Bliven
Jay Baumberger, low back, 2/10, $47,500, Stacy Tempel-St. John [Read more…]
By lilly
NEGLIGENCE: Suit against MDT properly dismissed for lack of expert as to standard of care as to road closure decisions where driver died from tree blown onto car by high wind… McNeil affirmed. [Read more…]
By lilly
CITY WATER: Summary judgment improper for City on contract/tort claims arising from loss of service due to frozen main… “illegal object” element improperly applied to implied contract where lot owner’s water derived from tap on subdivider’s service… ordinance’s bar of liability for [Read more…]
By lilly
MARITAL: Properties properly valued despite no final disclosure by husband prior to trial… wife bound by her filings which essentially allocated to husband certain premarital properties… $71,900 difference between husband’s ballpark figure for art and wife’s $28,100 appraised value properly attributed to husband… distribution of husband’s [Read more…]
By lilly
RIGHT TO BE PRESENT/PRO SE/INEFFECTIVE ASSISTANCE: 8th Judicial Dist. omnibus hearing not critical stage requiring Defendant’s presence… Defendant properly allowed to proceed pro se without separate hearing into complaints about lawyer… insufficient record of lawyer’s trial [Read more…]
By lilly
PROCEDURE: City has no appeal from District Court dismissal for lack of evidence in trial de novo… appeal dismissed with prejudice… opinion & order. [Read more…]
By lilly
VERDICT: $94,742.51, dog bite, nose scarring.
A Butte jury found 12-0 that Duchess bit Savannah Jelich and that Jelich did not provoke Duchess, and 9-3 that Jelich will be reasonably compensated by [Read more…]
By lilly
Plan I
Raymond Slater, foot, 10/10, disputed, $8,500, stipulated judgment; Eric Rasmusson for Slater, Kelly Wills for Roseburg Forest Products
David Keil, soft-tissue neck, 7/05, $200,000, Paul Odegaard [Read more…]
By Frank
CONTINUING TORT: Contamination that has stabilized as to quantity or concentration but continues to migrate will toll statute until harm no longer reasonably can be abated… certified question from Cebull. [Read more…]
By Frank
MEDICAL MALPRACTICE: Treating physician as non-retained expert improperly precluded from testimony as to standard of care of infant with low glucose, Defendant cannot claim surprise or prejudice from alleged insufficient notice as to opinions, while Plaintiff was unfairly prejudiced by mid-trial exclusion of [Read more…]