TRUST: Dispute over invasion of principal for wife’s care improperly resolved in favor of remainder beneficiary/trustee/grandson… trustee should be removed… prior accountings not needed to further explore breach of duties… McNeil reversed, affirmed (IOR I-3(d)). [Read more…]
Archives for February 2014
Summary judgment, no response brief, vexatious
SUMMARY JUDGMENT improper for intentional failure to file response brief to leverage a settlement without Rule 56 analysis, but de novo review reveals no fact issues that would preclude summary judgment on medical defamation claims… request to declare Plaintiff vexatious litigant denied, but Court may [Read more…]
Restitution, aggregate damages, vandalism spree
RESTITUTION improperly imposed jointly with other vandals for aggregate damages in 11-day spree when youth admitted to only 2 days… Watters reversed. [Read more…]
Restitution, extradition costs, Idaho apprehension
RESTITUTION improperly imposed for extradition costs when Montana escapee was “apprehended” by Idaho officers… Sherlock reversed. [Read more…]
Counterclaims, corporate dissolution, Rule 13(h)
COUNTERCLAIMS: Defendant who was sued as individual by corporation may only counterclaim as individual, not as shareholder, counterclaims for corporate dissolution, breach of fiduciary duty dismissed as improper counterclaims… [Read more…]
Defense verdict, med mal, disk replacement
VERDICT: Defense, med-mal, disk replacement. [Read more…]
Erisa, big/little HIPAA, claims handling/settlement
ERISA: Big HIPAA does not prohibit rating employers in purchasing consortium, preempts identical Montana statute, method of rating consortiums does not violate Montana’s little HIPAA… UTPA anti-discrimination statute cannot be used to [Read more…]
Defense verdict, chairlift unloading, hip
VERDICT: Defense, chairlift unloading injury, hip. [Read more…]
Early SSR, work injury, “retirement”
Petitioner who started receiving SSR at 62 and was injured at work at 63 is “retired,” not eligible for PTD… Shea. [Read more…]
Settlements
Plan I
James Spragg, knee/tibial plateau/T11, 10/11, disputed PTD, $16,842, medicals reserved, stipulated judgment; Norman Newhall for Spragg, [Read more…]