• Home
  • Current Issue
  • Category Search
    • Arbitration
    • DLI Hearings Bureau
    • Federal Trial Courts
    • Justice Courts
    • Ninth Circuit Court
    • State Trial Courts
    • Supreme Court – Civil
    • Supreme Court – Criminal
    • US Supreme Court
    • Bankruptcy Court
    • Workers’ Compensation Court
    • Board of Personnel Appeals
    • Human Rights
  • Indexes
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index – 2025
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index – 2024
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2023
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2022
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2021
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2020
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2019
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2018
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2017
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2016
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2015
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2014
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2013
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2012
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2011
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index – 2010
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2009
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index – 2008
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2007
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2006
  • Subscribe

Montana Law Week

The Weekly Digest of Montana Law

Archives for 2014

Railroads, hi-rail/freight train, supervision

May 17, 2014 By lilly

RAILROADS: Negligent mismanagement claim following hi-rail/freight train collision governed by unique Montana law, not preempted by RLA, fact issues as to employee’s and RR’s conduct leading to the collision preclude summary judgment… Cebull reversed. [Read more…]

Filed Under: Ninth Circuit Court, Past Issues Tagged With: Donald Munro, Sharon Van Dyck

Passport restriction, judicial usurpation of power

May 17, 2014 By lilly

PASSPORT RESTRICTION: Denial of discharged Defendant’s permission to apply for passport a “judicial usurpation of power” warranting mandamus… Haddon reversed.

Keith Faherty requested coram nobis relief from Judge Haddon’s denial of permission to apply for a new or replacement passport. We construe his request as a petition for mandamus. Span (9th Cir. 1996).

Mandamus is justified in “exceptional circumstances amounting to a judicial usurpation of power.” Bauman (9th Cir. 1977). Bauman identified 5 guidelines: (1) no other adequate means to attain relief; (2) petitioner will be damaged or prejudiced in a way not correctable on appeal; (3) order clearly erroneous as a matter of law; (4) order is an oft-repeated error or manifests a persistent disregard of the federal rules; (5) order raises new & important problems or issues of 1st impression. The US conceded at oral argument that the only guideline not met is the 4th.

Haddon’s assumption of jurisdiction over Faherty’s passport application was clearly erroneous. He had completed his sentence and supervised release. No case involving him was pending. By continuing to deny him the opportunity to pursue his right to travel, Haddon engaged in “judicial usurpation of power,” thereby warranting the extraordinary remedy of mandamus. The order is vacated. Haddon is ordered to forthwith and without limitation or restriction grant Faherty permission to apply for a new or replacement passport. The Dept. of State can then determine whether one should be issued.

Hawkins, Rawlinson, Bea.

US v. Faherty, 12-30340, 4/18/14.

Helge Naber, Great Falls, for Faherty; AUSAs Paulette Stewart & J. Bishop Grewell.

Filed Under: Ninth Circuit Court, Past Issues Tagged With: Helge Naber, J. Bishop Grewell, Paulette Stewart

Settlements

May 17, 2014 By lilly

Plan I

Yvonne Hutzenbiler, foot, 6/13, $1,500, stipulated judgment; Garry Seaman for Hutzenbiler, Todd Hammer for Rosauers Supermarkets [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Workers' Compensation Court

Lending breach, modification, misrepresentation

May 10, 2014 By lilly

LENDING BREACH: Breach of modification agreement properly rejected as not written or recorded… fact issues preclude summary judgment as to negligence, also as to negligent [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Supreme Court - Civil Tagged With: Adam Tunning, Christopher Oliveira, Chuck Munson, David Wilson, Doug James, Flint Murfitt, James Sturdevant, John Heenan, Jonathan McDonald, Kenneth Lay, Lawson Konvalinka, Robert Olsen

Probate, will, trust

May 10, 2014 By lilly

PROBATE: Joint will allowed surviving wife to establish trust during her life… Knisely reversed. [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Supreme Court - Civil Tagged With: George Kimmet, Gregory Johnson, John Jones, William Schreiber

Trust, trustees removal

May 10, 2014 By lilly

TRUST: Petition to remove trustees of family farm trust properly rejected… Cybulski affirmed (IOR I-3(d)). [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Supreme Court - Civil Tagged With: Brad Fjeldheim, Laura Christoffersen, Loren O’Toole II

Arbitration, home construction contract

May 10, 2014 By lilly

ARBITRATION clause in home construction contract enforceable… Ulbricht reversed. [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Supreme Court - Civil Tagged With: Amy Eddy, David Sandler, Scott Hagel

Land contract, illegal subdivision

May 10, 2014 By lilly

LAND CONTRACT void as impracticable because subdivision in forest illegal, not saved by intent to challenge law… Montana jurisdiction proper over contract signed in Idaho… Townsend affirmed (IOR I-3(d)). [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Supreme Court - Civil

Guardianship, failure to “immediately appeal”

May 10, 2014 By lilly

GUARDIANSHIP: Appeal of guardian appointment waived by failure to “immediately appeal”… Salvagni affirmed (IOR I-3(d)). [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Supreme Court - Civil Tagged With: Mark Miller

Paternity, alternative fathers, DNA

May 10, 2014 By lilly

PATERNITY assertion against 2nd putative father properly rejected following DNA test of 1st putative father… Krueger affirmed. [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Supreme Court - Civil Tagged With: Terry Schaplow, Todd Hillier

  • « Previous Page
  • 1
  • …
  • 35
  • 36
  • 37
  • 38
  • 39
  • …
  • 59
  • Next Page »

Login Status

Search This Website

Archives

  • ►2026
    • ▼November (19)
      • Insurance, Victory failed to disclose settled suit
      • CCJI, dissemination to ICE for non-criminal civil
      • Failure to appear for jury trial verification
      • Plea withdrawal, Judge was briefly Prosecutor
      • Obstruction, alleged JP and panelist bias
      • Jury oath, voir dire oath mistakenly read to jury
      • Arbitration, property management agreement
      • $289,750 verdict, wrongful discharge of snow plower
      • SSI/SSD, TBI that causes seizures
      • Attempted harboring of illegal, mens rea
      • Supervisory control, DEQ quasi-judicial immunity
      • Judge disqualification, "cumulative progression"
      • Water, beaver pens to irrigation/livestock
      • Privacy in communications, harassment of dispatcher
      • DUI, phlebotomist's qualifications, prior DUIs
      • DUI, phlebotomist's qualifications, jail draw
      • Libel, claims against attorney and media, UPEPA
      • Bench judgment, pasture easement by necessity
      • Data breach, arbitration denied, websites notice
    • ►October (39)
    • ►September (23)
    • ►August (43)
    • ►July (41)
    • ►June (29)
    • ►May (26)
    • ►April (29)
    • ►March (39)
    • ►February (43)
    • ►January (57)
  • ►2025
    • ►August (48)
    • ►July (40)
    • ►June (30)
    • ►May (42)
    • ►April (27)
    • ►March (43)
    • ►February (35)
    • ►January (32)
  • ►2024
    • ►December (41)
    • ►November (36)
    • ►October (24)
    • ►September (38)
    • ►August (44)
    • ►July (34)
    • ►June (47)
    • ►May (36)
    • ►April (33)
    • ►March (44)
    • ►February (32)
    • ►January (35)
  • ►2023
    • ►December (35)
    • ►November (35)
    • ►October (28)
    • ►September (36)
    • ►August (27)
    • ►July (40)
    • ►June (38)
    • ►May (40)
    • ►April (26)
    • ►March (29)
    • ►February (28)
    • ►January (23)
  • ►2022
    • ►December (39)
    • ►November (36)
    • ►October (41)
    • ►September (20)
    • ►August (30)
    • ►July (40)
    • ►June (28)
    • ►May (27)
    • ►April (28)
    • ►March (34)
    • ►February (31)
    • ►January (52)
  • ►2021
    • ►December (37)
    • ►November (37)
    • ►October (48)
    • ►September (37)
    • ►August (49)
    • ►July (43)
    • ►June (30)
    • ►May (52)
    • ►April (46)
    • ►March (39)
    • ►February (40)
    • ►January (16)
  • ►2020
    • ►December (36)
    • ►November (41)
    • ►October (43)
    • ►September (37)
    • ►August (46)
    • ►July (37)
    • ►June (41)
    • ►May (57)
    • ►April (39)
    • ►March (33)
    • ►February (41)
    • ►January (34)
  • ►2019
    • ►December (28)
    • ►November (43)
    • ►October (22)
    • ►September (42)
    • ►August (45)
    • ►July (31)
    • ►June (44)
    • ►May (37)
    • ►April (36)
    • ►March (46)
    • ►February (41)
    • ►January (30)
  • ►2018
    • ►December (52)
    • ►November (38)
    • ►October (30)
    • ►September (48)
    • ►August (38)
    • ►July (36)
    • ►June (48)
    • ►May (43)
    • ►April (48)
    • ►March (55)
    • ►February (44)
    • ►January (46)
  • ►2017
    • ►December (46)
    • ►November (42)
    • ►October (37)
    • ►September (51)
    • ►August (35)
    • ►July (56)
    • ►June (51)
    • ►May (49)
    • ►April (59)
    • ►March (39)
    • ►February (39)
    • ►January (41)
  • ►2016
    • ►December (51)
    • ►November (44)
    • ►October (53)
    • ►September (39)
    • ►August (36)
    • ►July (55)
    • ►June (38)
    • ►May (37)
    • ►April (55)
    • ►March (37)
    • ►February (29)
    • ►January (51)
  • ►2015
    • ►December (34)
    • ►November (33)
    • ►October (59)
    • ►September (43)
    • ►August (46)
    • ►July (44)
    • ►June (54)
    • ►May (58)
    • ►April (53)
    • ►March (43)
    • ►February (41)
    • ►January (47)
  • ►2014
    • ►December (45)
    • ►November (45)
    • ►October (42)
    • ►September (43)
    • ►August (56)
    • ►July (43)
    • ►June (54)
    • ►May (56)
    • ►April (57)
    • ►March (56)
    • ►February (48)
    • ►January (38)
  • ►2013
    • ►December (40)
    • ►November (52)
    • ►October (38)
    • ►September (46)
    • ►August (63)
    • ►July (47)
    • ►June (73)
    • ►May (43)
    • ►April (47)
    • ►March (69)
    • ►February (41)
    • ►January (36)
  • ►2012
    • ►December (49)
    • ►November (39)
    • ►October (46)
    • ►September (53)
    • ►August (51)
    • ►July (42)
    • ►June (52)
    • ►May (48)
    • ►April (44)
    • ►March (47)
    • ►February (37)
    • ►January (52)
  • ►2011
    • ►December (73)
    • ►November (71)
    • ►October (51)
    • ►September (35)
    • ►August (42)
    • ►July (62)
    • ►June (51)
    • ►May (38)
    • ►April (61)
    • ►March (44)
    • ►February (55)
    • ►January (64)
  • ►2010
    • ►December (45)
    • ►November (51)
    • ►October (65)
    • ►September (52)
    • ►August (37)
    • ►July (70)
    • ►June (45)
    • ►May (61)
    • ►April (52)
    • ►March (66)
    • ►February (51)
    • ►January (62)
  • ►2009
    • ►September (55)
    • ►August (60)
    • ►July (51)
    • ►June (32)
    • ►May (87)
    • ►April (56)
    • ►March (57)
    • ►February (55)
    • ►January (62)

Archives Dropdown

© Copyright 2026 Montana Law Week. All Rights Reserved.

Website, hosting, and design provided by JHW Development