• Home
  • Current Issue
  • Category Search
    • Arbitration
    • DLI Hearings Bureau
    • Federal Trial Courts
    • Justice Courts
    • Ninth Circuit Court
    • State Trial Courts
    • Supreme Court – Civil
    • Supreme Court – Criminal
    • US Supreme Court
    • Bankruptcy Court
    • Workers’ Compensation Court
    • Board of Personnel Appeals
    • Human Rights
  • Indexes
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index – 2025
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index – 2024
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2023
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2022
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2021
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2020
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2019
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2018
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2017
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2016
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2015
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2014
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2013
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2012
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2011
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index – 2010
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2009
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index – 2008
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2007
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2006
  • Subscribe

Montana Law Week

The Weekly Digest of Montana Law

Archives for November 2017

Statute of limitations, ARD, bankruptcy tolling

November 18, 2017 By lilly

STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS on ARD claim against BN tolled by bankruptcy order enjoining claims against Grace and “Affiliated Entities”… Pinski reversed. [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Supreme Court - Civil Tagged With: Allan McGarvey, Chad Knight, John Lacey

Water, ranch successors’ rights apportioned 70/30

November 18, 2017 By lilly

WATER: Ranch successors’ rights apportioned 70/30 based on 1909 decree… McFadden/McElyea affirmed.

James & Linda Quigley and Richard Beck own ranches in the Blackfoot River Basin which John Blair once owned as Finn Ranch. Geary (Powell Co. 1909) decreed 4 rights for irrigation from Nevada Creek to Blair. The ranch was split and sold in 1912. No deed transfer has reserved specific rights. Quigleys’ and Beck’s predecessors each filed 4 Nevada Creek claims based on Geary. During its preparation for the Blackfoot River Basin Temporary Preliminary Decree, DNRC noted that the 8 claims were based on the same 4 rights and that each party was claiming the entirety, exceeding total appropriations, and attached a “decree extended” issue remark to the 8 claims. The parties filed objections. Following a trial and site visit, Water Master Hugh McFadden concluded that both Quigleys and Beck were successors to a portion of Blair’s Nevada Creek rights and split the flow rates based on historic acres irrigated pursuant to the Spaeth (Mont. 1963) formula, resulting in 70% to Beck and 30% to Quigleys. Judge McElyea largely adopted the report. Quigleys appeal.

McElyea and McFadden correctly interpreted Geary in the context of the facts and law. Blair’s answer, amended answer, and pleadings do not control the place of use of the rights decreed to him, and therefore Geary does not prevent the Nevada Creek rights from being made appurtenant to Beck’s lands.

McFadden did not clearly err in his findings and properly applied the Spaeth formula to divide the water rights, and McElyea correctly applied the clear error analysis to McFadden’s findings. Inter alia, McElyea concluded that Quigley failed to prove that the formula should be adjusted to allocate flow rates differently based on soil differences.

Baker, McGrath, Wheat, Sandefur, Rice.

Quigley and Beck, Objectors, DA 16-629, 11/14/17.

Ryan Mattick (Moore, O’Connell & Refling), Bozeman, for Quigleys; John Bloomquist (Bloomquist Law Firm), Helena, for Beck.

Filed Under: Past Issues, Supreme Court - Civil Tagged With: John Bloomquist, Ryan Mattick

Marital, attorney mother, parenting plan

November 18, 2017 By lilly

MARITAL: Attorney mother’s appeal of parenting plan rejected… Cooney affirmed (IOR I-3(c)). [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Supreme Court - Civil Tagged With: Robyn Weber

Marital, parenting, property

November 18, 2017 By lilly

MARITAL: Parenting, property issues properly resolved… Pinski affirmed (IOR I-3(c)). [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Supreme Court - Civil Tagged With: Roberta Cross Guns

Insurance, UIM fee opinion amended

November 18, 2017 By lilly

INSURANCE: UIM fee opinion amended… order. [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Supreme Court - Civil Tagged With: Patrick Fox, Paul Haffeman, Rick Pyfer

Sexual assault, nolo plea/sentence

November 18, 2017 By lilly

SEXUAL ASSAULT: Nolo plea pursuant to agreement improperly accepted… Sandefur reversed. [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Supreme Court – Criminal Tagged With: Carey Haight, Chad Vanisko, Ryan Aikin

$52,348 verdict, construction lien, no negligence

November 18, 2017 By lilly

VERDICT: $52,348 for construction lien, no negligence on counterclaim. [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, State Trial Courts Tagged With: Brian Miller, Katie Guffin, Lucas Mann, Marcel Quinn, Robert Olson, Robert Pfennigs, Shelly Brander

Insurance, $2.5 million punitives to $1,064,282.44

November 18, 2017 By lilly

INSURANCE: $2.5 million punitives for failure to unconditionally pay UIM to motorcyclist’s estate cut to $1,064,282.44 (4-1 ratio)… attorney expert testimony upheld… new trial not warranted by failure to produce documents during time Plaintiff and attorney conferred as “friends”… Anderson affirmed, reversed (unpublished). [Read more…]

Filed Under: Ninth Circuit Court, Past Issues Tagged With: Cathy Lewis, Christopher Sweeney, Gerry Fagan, John Heenan, Jordan Crosby, Mary Jaraczeski, Randall Bishop, Robert James

Settlements

November 18, 2017 By lilly

Plan I

Lynn Trenary, ear(s), 6/16, disputed, $32,500, Rick Pyfer

Beverley DeMary, upper extremities, 4/14, $30,000, Michele Levine [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Workers' Compensation Court

Serial litigation, amended complaint

November 11, 2017 By lilly

SERIAL LITIGATION: Amended complaint did not constitute serial litigation as 2nd Judge was not asked for “the same order” as 1st Judge… Ortley reversed. [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Supreme Court - Civil Tagged With: Ben Snipes, Brian Smith, Mark Kovacich, Michael McKeon Jr, Scott Hagel, Tessa Keller

  • « Previous Page
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Next Page »

Login Status

Search This Website

Archives

  • ►2026
    • ▼November (9)
      • Supervisory control, DEQ quasi-judicial immunity
      • Judge disqualification, "cumulative progression"
      • Water, beaver pens to irrigation/livestock
      • Privacy in communications, harassment of dispatcher
      • DUI, phlebotomist's qualifications, prior DUIs
      • DUI, phlebotomist's qualifications, jail draw
      • Libel, claims against attorney and media, UPEPA
      • Bench judgment, pasture easement by necessity
      • Data breach, arbitration denied, websites notice
    • ►October (39)
    • ►September (23)
    • ►August (43)
    • ►July (41)
    • ►June (29)
    • ►May (26)
    • ►April (29)
    • ►March (39)
    • ►February (43)
    • ►January (57)
  • ►2025
    • ►August (48)
    • ►July (40)
    • ►June (30)
    • ►May (42)
    • ►April (27)
    • ►March (43)
    • ►February (35)
    • ►January (32)
  • ►2024
    • ►December (41)
    • ►November (36)
    • ►October (24)
    • ►September (38)
    • ►August (44)
    • ►July (34)
    • ►June (47)
    • ►May (36)
    • ►April (33)
    • ►March (44)
    • ►February (32)
    • ►January (35)
  • ►2023
    • ►December (35)
    • ►November (35)
    • ►October (28)
    • ►September (36)
    • ►August (27)
    • ►July (40)
    • ►June (38)
    • ►May (40)
    • ►April (26)
    • ►March (29)
    • ►February (28)
    • ►January (23)
  • ►2022
    • ►December (39)
    • ►November (36)
    • ►October (41)
    • ►September (20)
    • ►August (30)
    • ►July (40)
    • ►June (28)
    • ►May (27)
    • ►April (28)
    • ►March (34)
    • ►February (31)
    • ►January (52)
  • ►2021
    • ►December (37)
    • ►November (37)
    • ►October (48)
    • ►September (37)
    • ►August (49)
    • ►July (43)
    • ►June (30)
    • ►May (52)
    • ►April (46)
    • ►March (39)
    • ►February (40)
    • ►January (16)
  • ►2020
    • ►December (36)
    • ►November (41)
    • ►October (43)
    • ►September (37)
    • ►August (46)
    • ►July (37)
    • ►June (41)
    • ►May (57)
    • ►April (39)
    • ►March (33)
    • ►February (41)
    • ►January (34)
  • ►2019
    • ►December (28)
    • ►November (43)
    • ►October (22)
    • ►September (42)
    • ►August (45)
    • ►July (31)
    • ►June (44)
    • ►May (37)
    • ►April (36)
    • ►March (46)
    • ►February (41)
    • ►January (30)
  • ►2018
    • ►December (52)
    • ►November (38)
    • ►October (30)
    • ►September (48)
    • ►August (38)
    • ►July (36)
    • ►June (48)
    • ►May (43)
    • ►April (48)
    • ►March (55)
    • ►February (44)
    • ►January (46)
  • ►2017
    • ►December (46)
    • ►November (42)
    • ►October (37)
    • ►September (51)
    • ►August (35)
    • ►July (56)
    • ►June (51)
    • ►May (49)
    • ►April (59)
    • ►March (39)
    • ►February (39)
    • ►January (41)
  • ►2016
    • ►December (51)
    • ►November (44)
    • ►October (53)
    • ►September (39)
    • ►August (36)
    • ►July (55)
    • ►June (38)
    • ►May (37)
    • ►April (55)
    • ►March (37)
    • ►February (29)
    • ►January (51)
  • ►2015
    • ►December (34)
    • ►November (33)
    • ►October (59)
    • ►September (43)
    • ►August (46)
    • ►July (44)
    • ►June (54)
    • ►May (58)
    • ►April (53)
    • ►March (43)
    • ►February (41)
    • ►January (47)
  • ►2014
    • ►December (45)
    • ►November (45)
    • ►October (42)
    • ►September (43)
    • ►August (56)
    • ►July (43)
    • ►June (54)
    • ►May (56)
    • ►April (57)
    • ►March (56)
    • ►February (48)
    • ►January (38)
  • ►2013
    • ►December (40)
    • ►November (52)
    • ►October (38)
    • ►September (46)
    • ►August (63)
    • ►July (47)
    • ►June (73)
    • ►May (43)
    • ►April (47)
    • ►March (69)
    • ►February (41)
    • ►January (36)
  • ►2012
    • ►December (49)
    • ►November (39)
    • ►October (46)
    • ►September (53)
    • ►August (51)
    • ►July (42)
    • ►June (52)
    • ►May (48)
    • ►April (44)
    • ►March (47)
    • ►February (37)
    • ►January (52)
  • ►2011
    • ►December (73)
    • ►November (71)
    • ►October (51)
    • ►September (35)
    • ►August (42)
    • ►July (62)
    • ►June (51)
    • ►May (38)
    • ►April (61)
    • ►March (44)
    • ►February (55)
    • ►January (64)
  • ►2010
    • ►December (45)
    • ►November (51)
    • ►October (65)
    • ►September (52)
    • ►August (37)
    • ►July (70)
    • ►June (45)
    • ►May (61)
    • ►April (52)
    • ►March (66)
    • ►February (51)
    • ►January (62)
  • ►2009
    • ►September (55)
    • ►August (60)
    • ►July (51)
    • ►June (32)
    • ►May (87)
    • ►April (56)
    • ►March (57)
    • ►February (55)
    • ►January (62)

Archives Dropdown

© Copyright 2026 Montana Law Week. All Rights Reserved.

Website, hosting, and design provided by JHW Development