CONTRACT PREPAYMENT: Purchaser properly held not to have fully performed under note or indenture by sellers’ acceptance of full prepayment amount while additional tax liability remained in dispute, but ambiguous prepayment clause improperly construed in favor of sellers resulting in damage award 8 times the stipulated federal tax liability… Wilson affirmed, reversed. [Read more…]
Archives for August 2020
Settlement, signed handwritten, unsigned formalized
SETTLEMENT: Formalized agreement based on signed handwritten agreement between MSP prisoner and parents of his granddaughter whom he was convicted of sexually assaulting properly declared enforceable… Rieger affirmed (IOR I-3(c)). [Read more…]
Receivership pendente lite, Glacier Co. “mismanagement”
RECEIVERSHIP PENDENTE LITE improperly appointed in challenge to Glacier Co. Commissioners’ and Treasurer’s alleged mismanagement… Pinski reversed. [Read more…]
Elections, Green Party ballot status
ELECTIONS: Green Party properly excluded from general election… order with opinion to follow… Reynolds affirmed. [Read more…]
Failure to yield, other driver/witnesses not called
FAILURE TO YIELD: Prosecutor not required to call other driver or MVA witnesses to satisfy Defendant’s confrontation right, officer’s testimony sufficient for conviction… Happe/Gilbert affirmed (IOR I-3(c)). [Read more…]
Theft, failure to refund purchase, criminal v. civil
THEFT: Failure to refund purchase price of canceled cooler sale properly pursued as criminal rather than civil… Happe/Gilbert affirmed (IOR I-3(c)). [Read more…]
Discovery, vehicle rental company 30(b)(6) designees
DISCOVERY: Vehicle rental company compelled to produce thoroughly educated & prepared 30(b)(6) designees to address topics listed in wrongful death Plaintiffs’ notices (all topics, not just topics specifically identified in Order, to avoid further pettifogging and taking a mile when given an inch), failure to provide knowledgeable designees shall be contempt of court… given Plaintiffs’ failure to specifically request what they now seek and that the materials were ultimately disclosed, sanctions under 37(c) are not appropriate, any other result would value the discovery motion more than the discovery… Molloy. [Read more…]
Settlements
Plan I
Steve Melkoty, lumbar spine, 2/11, head, cervical spine, elbow, shoulder, 5/19, Bigfork School Dist., MSGIA accepted claims, paid benefits, claims for lumbar injuries in 1/15, 12/15, and 5/18 are included in this settlement, placed at MMI in 3/20, dispute as to extent of disability entitlement and additional treatment, $125,000 for all claims, stipulated judgment; Dean Blackaby for Melkoty, Morgan Weber for MSGIA [Read more…]
Sovereign immunity, Reservation casino trip & fall
SOVEREIGN IMMUNITY: Reservation casino is arm of CSKT, enjoys immunity from trip & fall suit by Missoula residents… Bradley Pluff. [Read more…]
Pleadings, wind farm suit amendments, counterclaims
PLEADINGS: Ranchers’ amendments to Answer in opposition to neighbors’ challenge to wind farm properly denied as untimely but counterclaims alleging abuse of process improperly dismissed with prejudice as compulsory, may be asserted in independent action… Oldenburg affirmed, reversed. [Read more…]