CHILD INCEST: Child’s prior statements regarding alleged “false accusation” of sexual assault properly excluded under rape shield balancing… not clear whether “playing doctor” and “sleeping” with cousin when both were 5 were sexual… conviction of sexual abuse of granddaughter affirmed… Best affirmed. [Read more…]
Archives for August 2022
Long-term care insurance, claim of lifetime home care
LONG-TERM CARE INSURANCE: Lifetime home care and numerous other claims under Long Term Care Policy and HomeCare Recovery Policy rejected on summary judgment… Christensen. [Read more…]
Interim TTD, low back condition sequelae of leg injury
Interim TTD award for low back condition sequelae of leg injury supported by prima facie case with conflicting medical opinions… Sandler. [Read more…]
Settlements
Plan II
Scott McCoy, right shoulder, bruised right ribs, concussion, 1/21, yard leader at Builders First Source, Helena, right rotator cuff repair in 9/21 after which Dr. Stayner declared MMI and released to work with restrictions. Liberty accepted liability, paid wage & medical, disputes as to wage, impairment, voc-rehab, medical, $65,000 new money for all claims, stipulated judgment; Michael Doggett for McCoy, Michael Heringer for Liberty Mutual Ins. [Read more…]
Appellate procedure, denial of stay pending appeal
APPELLATE PROCEDURE: Denial of stay pending appeal of reversal of coal strip-mine permit reversed… Bidegaray reversed (order). [Read more…]
Supreme Court districting, HB 325 enjoined
SUPREME COURT DISTRICTING: HB 325 referendum properly enjoined from November ballot… Ohman affirmed. [Read more…]
Abortion services, 2021 restrictions preliminary enjoined
ABORTION SERVICES: 2021 laws regulating or restricting abortions properly preliminarily enjoined… Moses affirmed. [Read more…]
Child incest, encouraging stepson to touch breasts
CHILD INCEST: Defense’s request to interview children properly denied… fair trial of stepmother accused of encouraging stepson to touch her breasts not violated by State’s failure to lodge forensic interviews of children from a different case involving Defendant’s husband… plain error review of failure to give specific unanimity instruction in light of conviction on 1 count and acquittal on 1 count declined… conviction affirmed… Olson affirmed. [Read more…]
Sentencing, sex offender registration improperly imposed
SENTENCING: Sex offender registration and other conditions improperly imposed on sex assault Defendant… Dayton reversed (order). [Read more…]
Buy-sell, failure to obtain committee approval of home
BUY-SELL: Failure to obtain Architectural Committee approval of home not specifically stated as circumstance in which the buy-sell terminates, not grounds for termination, summary judgment for buyer on contract claim… material fact issues as to whether seller breached the implied covenant by interfering with the committee’s approval so he could terminate the buy-sell… buyer entitled to attorney fees per buy-sell… Rienne McElyea. [Read more…]