THEFT BY DECEPTION: Overlapping convictions for substandard or incomplete residential construction and roofing in Missoula and L&C Counties affirmed over claim of double jeopardy… imposition of a future consecutive Gallatin sentence stricken… Larson affirmed, reversed (memorandum). [Read more…]
Archives for October 2026
Plea withdrawal, plea agreement breach, timeliness
PLEA WITHDRAWAL for alleged breach of plea agreement properly denied as untimely under Peterson… Parker affirmed (other grounds) (memorandum). [Read more…]
Speedy trial, 630 days pretrial incarceration, reversed
SPEEDY TRIAL: 630 days of pretrial incarceration due in part to outsourcing analysis of digital devices requires reversal of conviction of SIWC of minor and dismissal of the charge… Kutzman reversed. [Read more…]
Collateral estoppel, storage units dispute
COLLATERAL ESTOPPEL: Complaint and materials properly considered under 12(b)(6) did not establish issue preclusion conclusively, and the Court could not resolve the settlement dispute involving storage units by relying on matters outside the pleadings without following 12(d)… Berger reversed. [Read more…]
Marital, home/business valuation, inheritance
MARITAL: Decree properly issued over challenges to home/business valuations, 3rd-party ownership of assets, use of wife’s inheritance, best interests of children with special needs who require housing stability… Larson affirmed. [Read more…]
Order of protection, stalking ex-girlfriend
ORDER OF PROTECTION properly granted for stalking ex-girlfriend… Hummel/Coffman affirmed (memorandum). [Read more…]
Elections, preliminary injunction of ballot issue stayed
ELECTIONS: Preliminary injunction by Larson issued from the bench and later in writing ordering correction of ballots that do not include ballot issue to switch elections of county officials to partisan ordered stayed… Order. [Read more…]
Supervisory control, denial of TOP for children
SUPERVISORY CONTROL of McElyea denied as to denial of father’s petition for a TOP for children allegedly abused in mother’s home… Order. [Read more…]
Defamation claim against outdoor sports Instagramer
DEFAMATION/TORTIOUS interference claims by fired outdoor sports employee against outdoor sports Instagramer properly rejected… Morris affirmed (memorandum). [Read more…]