PFMA: Conviction affirmed over challenge to officer being called to testify to backpedaling girlfriend’s gestures and mouthing to Defendant “I love you” while testifying to impeach her credibility and motivation for changing her testimony… Defendant entitled to credit for time at RCM under court order… Larson affirmed, reversed. [Read more…]
Youth, subordinating/superordinating construction
YOUTH: Court exceeded authority in sentencing 13-year-old to DOC to age 18 in light of subordinating/superordinating canon of construction of “subject to” and incorrect statutory interpretation supplied by counsel… remanded to sentence to maximum of 3 years… Murnion reversed. [Read more…]
Vehicle stop, speed by “pacing,” expanded to drug search
VEHICLE STOP: Claim that officer’s “pacing” was insufficient to stop for speeding was a new theory on appeal going beyond a change in emphasis, not preserved… stop not impermissibly expanded by discussing a drug investigation and requesting consent to search vehicle… suppression of drugs seized from vehicle and home properly denied… Harris affirmed. [Read more…]
Deliberate homicide, waiver of jury trial, oral consent
DELIBERATE HOMICIDE: Claim of inadequate waiver of jury by Defendant with mental issues who admitted killing and State’s oral (but not written) consent to bench trial rejected… ineffective assistance claims deferred to postconviction… Marks affirmed (memorandum). [Read more…]
Supervisory control, Justice Court recording
SUPERVISORY CONTROL of Mantooth denied as to arrest of friend recording pre-jury selection… Justice Court has authority to impose restrictions on recording… first impression… Order. [Read more…]
Felony murder/tampering, directed verdict denial
FELONY MURDER/TAMPERING convictions affirmed over challenge to denial of directed verdict… Abbott affirmed. [Read more…]
Theft by deception/deceptive practices, builder/roofer
THEFT BY DECEPTION: Overlapping convictions for substandard or incomplete residential construction and roofing in Missoula and L&C Counties affirmed over claim of double jeopardy… imposition of a future consecutive Gallatin sentence stricken… Larson affirmed, reversed (memorandum). [Read more…]
Plea withdrawal, plea agreement breach, timeliness
PLEA WITHDRAWAL for alleged breach of plea agreement properly denied as untimely under Peterson… Parker affirmed (other grounds) (memorandum). [Read more…]
Speedy trial, 630 days pretrial incarceration, reversed
SPEEDY TRIAL: 630 days of pretrial incarceration due in part to outsourcing analysis of digital devices requires reversal of conviction of SIWC of minor and dismissal of the charge… Kutzman reversed. [Read more…]
Deliberate homicide, statements to officers
DELIBERATE HOMICIDE: Convictions affirmed over challenge to admission of statements to officers… Wilson affirmed. [Read more…]