LLC DISSOCIATION: $2,420,000 compensatory damages verdict in favor of farm/ranch LLC and against departing members affirmed, but $80,000 punitives verdict reversed as action arose from Operating Agreement… 8-year contract statute properly applied in “twilight zone of contract and tort law”… dissociation date properly fixed at 2/2/18… departing members’ 2 shares properly valued at $434,000 each with 7.5% interest accruing from 2/2/18… Laird affirmed, reversed. [Read more…]
12(b)(6) dismissal with v. without prejudice
12(b)(6) DISMISSAL: MVA Plaintiffs’ claim that medical providers charged impermissible rates failed to demonstrate “concrete” harm and thus Article III standing, but should have been dismissed without prejudice to allow amendment… Morris affirmed, reversed (memorandum). [Read more…]
Insurance, UTPA/UIM, no injury from MVA
INSURANCE: UTPA/UIM claims properly disposed of by jury finding no injury from MVA over claims of unfair trial due to exclusion of claims file, denial of bifurcation, refusal to excuse panelist for cause, Judge asking jurors if they wanted to hear any more about witness’s qualifications, cumulative error… Menahan affirmed (memorandum). [Read more…]
Discovery, baler bearing wildfire, closed claim files
DISCOVERY: Supervisory control of Best denied in baler bearing wildfire case as to compelling discovery of Deere’s closed claim files from 1993 to present along with Plaintiffs’ version of a protective order allowing them to share documents with attorneys in similar cases… order. [Read more…]
Defense verdict, UIM/UTPA claims by former agent
VERDICT: Defense, UIM/UTPA claims by former insurance agent stemming from rear-end MVA. [Read more…]
Insurance, refusal to produce entire claim file
INSURANCE: Conserving resources insufficient for supervisory control of Menahan’s refusal to order insurer to produce entire MVA/UTPA claims file… order. [Read more…]
Judge substitution, 10 days from “arraignment”
JUDGE SUBSTITUTION: 10 days from “arraignment” to move for substitution begins at actual appearance (physical or audio-video). . . supervisory control of Pinski granted setting aside denial of motion based on determination that it began at initial arraignment setting at which Defendant did not appear. . . order. [Read more…]
Venue, vehicle pushed across county line
VENUE properly changed from Cascade to Glacier (Defendant’s residence) where MVA occurred in Teton but vehicle came to rest in Cascade… venue waiver based on order of docketing multiple simultaneous pleadings denied… Macek affirmed. [Read more…]
Attorney fees, wrongful premium retention
ATTORNEY FEES in wrongful premium retention class action settlement reduced from $1,650,408 to $692,881 in light of further analysis of settlement value, not on basis of 60(b)(2) new evidence, but on basis of 60(b)(6) extraordinary circumstances and agreement that fees shall be determined by the Court… Molloy. [Read more…]
Venue, in-state/out-of-state defendants
VENUE improperly changed from Plaintiff’s county to Montana Defendant’s under Nelson and §25-2-122(2) where co-Defendant is out-of-state corporation… Defendant-Appellee’s argument that application of venue statutes infringes equal protection considered despite no AG [Read more…]