SETTLEMENT: $550,000, traffic stop shooting death of suspected robber or drug shooter, eve of trial settlement following denial of summary judgment on whether deadly force was justified. [Read more…]
Excessive force death, backseat passenger, unlit plate
EXCESSIVE FORCE DEATH: Shooting of suspected robbery or drug shooter in stop of vehicle for alleged unlit plate light in which suspect was backseat passenger survives summary judgment as to whether deadly force was constitutional and — until facts can be established — whether officer violated clearly established law… summary judgment for City and PD granted on §1983 claims… summary judgment granted and denied on state law claims… Molloy. [Read more…]
$262,922.03 judgment, luxury house construction lien
BENCH JUDGMENT: Defense as to claims of $6,363,597 plus attorney fees & interest against luxury home contractor. . . $262,922.03 to contractor on construction lien. . . Todd. [Read more…]
Wrongful discharge, insubordination v. reasonableness
WRONGFUL DISCHARGE: Termination of superintendent for refusing to follow directives to safeguard heavy equipment properly upheld on summary judgment over employee’s contention that reasonableness of refusal was jury issue. . . Todd affirmed (IOR I-3(c)). [Read more…]
Minerals, “rare and exceptional” dinosaur fossils
MINERALS: “Rare and exceptional” dinosaur fossils are “minerals” pursuant to Montana law and terms of Deed and belong to owners of the mineral estate. . . Watters reversed. [Read more…]
Right to know, $1.6 million police judgment documents
RIGHT TO KNOW: Blanket challenge to attorney-client and work-product privilege assertions insufficient to compel disclosure of documents related to $1.6 million policeman judgment. . . Moses affirmed. [Read more…]
Public duty, officer as sole cause of harm
PUBLIC DUTY: Certified question from 9th Circuit accepted as to whether Montana public duty doctrine shields an officer from negligence liability where he is the sole cause of the plaintiff’s harm… order. [Read more…]
Public duty, officer as cause of plaintiff’s harm
PUBLIC DUTY: Question certified as to whether Montana public duty doctrine shields an officer from negligence liability where he is the sole cause of the plaintiff’s harm, in appeal from ruling by Haddon that it does shield him… order. [Read more…]
Indemnity agreements, “appropriate expenses”
INDEMNITY AGREEMENTS: Summary judgment properly granted on limited issue of whether insurer may seek indemnification from contractor for “appropriate expenses” incurred in payment litigation by subcontractor, issue of damages to be decided by trier of fact including whether fees which contractor alleges were incurred by insurer defending against bad faith claim in underlying litigation are covered… Moses affirmed. [Read more…]
Minerals, dinosaur fossils, “ordinary & natural”
MINERALS: Fossils not in ordinary & natural definition of “mineral” in general mineral deed, highly valuable Dueling Dinosaurs, Murray T. Rex, Triceratops fossils found on ranch not part of mineral estate, surface owners are sole owners… Watters. [Read more…]