• Home
  • Current Issue
  • Category Search
    • Arbitration
    • DLI Hearings Bureau
    • Federal Trial Courts
    • Justice Courts
    • Ninth Circuit Court
    • State Trial Courts
    • Supreme Court – Civil
    • Supreme Court – Criminal
    • US Supreme Court
    • Bankruptcy Court
    • Workers’ Compensation Court
    • Board of Personnel Appeals
    • Human Rights
  • Indexes
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index – 2025
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index – 2024
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2023
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2022
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2021
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2020
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2019
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2018
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2017
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2016
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2015
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2014
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2013
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2012
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2011
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index – 2010
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2009
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index – 2008
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2007
    • Montana Law Week Subject Index- 2006
  • Subscribe

Montana Law Week

The Weekly Digest of Montana Law

Deliberate homicide, Prosecutor’s statements/comments

February 4, 2023 By lilly

DELIBERATE HOMICIDE: Failure to object to Prosecutor’s improper or borderline improper statements and comments regarding Defendant accused of disappearing his girlfriend not ineffective assistance especially in light of independent evidence of guilt and his own trial admissions… Best affirmed (memorandum). [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Supreme Court – Criminal Tagged With: Joseph Howard, Mardell Ployhar

Waiver of counsel, awareness of PFO penalties

December 17, 2022 By lilly

WAIVER OF COUNSEL: Counsel intelligently waived as robbery Defendant knew risks and was advised of potential PFO-enhanced penalties and sentenced well within range… Eddy affirmed. [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Supreme Court – Criminal Tagged With: Andrew Clegg, Carolyn Gibadlo, Mardell Ployhar

Theft, Defendant caught driving stolen truck

October 22, 2022 By lilly

THEFT: Defendant caught driving stolen truck that he claimed he was hired to drive to South Dakota properly convicted despite no instructions on results-based definitions of knowingly and purposely… Murnion affirmed (memorandum). [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Supreme Court – Criminal Tagged With: Joseph Howard, Mardell Ployhar

Ineffective assistance, divorce attorney, theft

October 1, 2022 By lilly

INEFFECTIVE ASSISTANCE: Claim that divorce attorney was ineffective resulting in statements that should be suppressed in criminal prosecution fails because there is no right to counsel in a divorce… Olson affirmed (memorandum). [Read more…]

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: Colin Stephens, Mardell Ployhar

Rape, alleged fabrication to avoid revocation

September 17, 2022 By lilly

RAPE: Evidence purporting to show that accuser was motivated to fabricate to avoid jail for violating conditional release properly excluded… Defendant properly limited in attempt to impeach accuser about leniency she allegedly received on pending DUI in another county… disqualification of entire county attorney office due to meritless claim that CA had confidential information from representing Defendant in 2011 properly denied… conviction affirmed… Christopher affirmed. [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Supreme Court – Criminal Tagged With: Brendan McQuillan, Chad Wright, Mardell Ployhar

Incest, 100 years prison no parole for 30 years

July 2, 2022 By lilly

INCEST: Plain error review of sentence of 100 years at MSP no parole for 30 years denied… Dayton affirmed (memorandum). [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Supreme Court – Criminal Tagged With: Mardell Ployhar, Penelope Strong

Mistrial, failure to appear, assault with weapon

June 18, 2022 By lilly

MISTRIAL: Claim that attorney was ineffective in not opposing mistrial for Defendant’s failure to appear rejected… assault with weapon conviction affirmed… Ruiz affirmed (memorandum). [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Supreme Court – Criminal Tagged With: Colin Stephens, Mardell Ployhar

Rape, ineffective assistance, 5 attorneys, 2 trials

June 4, 2022 By lilly

RAPE: Ineffective assistance not established against any of 5 attorneys in 2 trials… Ulbricht affirmed (memorandum). [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Supreme Court – Criminal Tagged With: Mardell Ployhar, Penelope Strong

Rape, mid-trial amended information to correct charge

February 26, 2022 By lilly

RAPE: State properly allowed to file a 3rd Amended Information mid-trial after Judge discovered error in charging SIWC under 2017 aggravated SIWC statute that was not effective at time of charged offense… instruction on consent not reversible under plain error review… convictions affirmed… McMahon affirmed. [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Supreme Court – Criminal Tagged With: Chad Wright, Jeremy Gersovitz, Katie Jerstad, Mardell Ployhar

Rape, false reporting statistics

January 29, 2022 By lilly

RAPE: Counsel’s failure to object to expert testimony as to false reporting statistics was ineffective assistance, prejudicial in that objection might have resulted in acquittal… rape conviction reversed, remanded for new trial… other charges involving girlfriend affirmed… Reynolds reversed, affirmed. [Read more…]

Filed Under: Past Issues, Supreme Court – Criminal Tagged With: Mardell Ployhar, Michael Marchesini

  • « Previous Page
  • 1
  • …
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • …
  • 26
  • Next Page »

Login Status

Search This Website

Archives

  • ►2026
    • ▼October (6)
      • Collateral estoppel, storage units dispute
      • Marital, home/business valuation, inheritance
      • Order of protection, stalking ex-girlfriend
      • Elections, preliminary injunction of ballot issue stayed
      • Supervisory control, denial of TOP for children
      • Defamation claim against outdoor sports Instagramer
    • ►September (23)
    • ►August (43)
    • ►July (41)
    • ►June (29)
    • ►May (26)
    • ►April (29)
    • ►March (39)
    • ►February (43)
    • ►January (57)
  • ►2025
    • ►August (48)
    • ►July (40)
    • ►June (30)
    • ►May (42)
    • ►April (27)
    • ►March (43)
    • ►February (35)
    • ►January (32)
  • ►2024
    • ►December (41)
    • ►November (36)
    • ►October (24)
    • ►September (38)
    • ►August (44)
    • ►July (34)
    • ►June (47)
    • ►May (36)
    • ►April (33)
    • ►March (44)
    • ►February (32)
    • ►January (35)
  • ►2023
    • ►December (35)
    • ►November (35)
    • ►October (28)
    • ►September (36)
    • ►August (27)
    • ►July (40)
    • ►June (38)
    • ►May (40)
    • ►April (26)
    • ►March (29)
    • ►February (28)
    • ►January (23)
  • ►2022
    • ►December (39)
    • ►November (36)
    • ►October (41)
    • ►September (20)
    • ►August (30)
    • ►July (40)
    • ►June (28)
    • ►May (27)
    • ►April (28)
    • ►March (34)
    • ►February (31)
    • ►January (52)
  • ►2021
    • ►December (37)
    • ►November (37)
    • ►October (48)
    • ►September (37)
    • ►August (49)
    • ►July (43)
    • ►June (30)
    • ►May (52)
    • ►April (46)
    • ►March (39)
    • ►February (40)
    • ►January (16)
  • ►2020
    • ►December (36)
    • ►November (41)
    • ►October (43)
    • ►September (37)
    • ►August (46)
    • ►July (37)
    • ►June (41)
    • ►May (57)
    • ►April (39)
    • ►March (33)
    • ►February (41)
    • ►January (34)
  • ►2019
    • ►December (28)
    • ►November (43)
    • ►October (22)
    • ►September (42)
    • ►August (45)
    • ►July (31)
    • ►June (44)
    • ►May (37)
    • ►April (36)
    • ►March (46)
    • ►February (41)
    • ►January (30)
  • ►2018
    • ►December (52)
    • ►November (38)
    • ►October (30)
    • ►September (48)
    • ►August (38)
    • ►July (36)
    • ►June (48)
    • ►May (43)
    • ►April (48)
    • ►March (55)
    • ►February (44)
    • ►January (46)
  • ►2017
    • ►December (46)
    • ►November (42)
    • ►October (37)
    • ►September (51)
    • ►August (35)
    • ►July (56)
    • ►June (51)
    • ►May (49)
    • ►April (59)
    • ►March (39)
    • ►February (39)
    • ►January (41)
  • ►2016
    • ►December (51)
    • ►November (44)
    • ►October (53)
    • ►September (39)
    • ►August (36)
    • ►July (55)
    • ►June (38)
    • ►May (37)
    • ►April (55)
    • ►March (37)
    • ►February (29)
    • ►January (51)
  • ►2015
    • ►December (34)
    • ►November (33)
    • ►October (59)
    • ►September (43)
    • ►August (46)
    • ►July (44)
    • ►June (54)
    • ►May (58)
    • ►April (53)
    • ►March (43)
    • ►February (41)
    • ►January (47)
  • ►2014
    • ►December (45)
    • ►November (45)
    • ►October (42)
    • ►September (43)
    • ►August (56)
    • ►July (43)
    • ►June (54)
    • ►May (56)
    • ►April (57)
    • ►March (56)
    • ►February (48)
    • ►January (38)
  • ►2013
    • ►December (40)
    • ►November (52)
    • ►October (38)
    • ►September (46)
    • ►August (63)
    • ►July (47)
    • ►June (73)
    • ►May (43)
    • ►April (47)
    • ►March (69)
    • ►February (41)
    • ►January (36)
  • ►2012
    • ►December (49)
    • ►November (39)
    • ►October (46)
    • ►September (53)
    • ►August (51)
    • ►July (42)
    • ►June (52)
    • ►May (48)
    • ►April (44)
    • ►March (47)
    • ►February (37)
    • ►January (52)
  • ►2011
    • ►December (73)
    • ►November (71)
    • ►October (51)
    • ►September (35)
    • ►August (42)
    • ►July (62)
    • ►June (51)
    • ►May (38)
    • ►April (61)
    • ►March (44)
    • ►February (55)
    • ►January (64)
  • ►2010
    • ►December (45)
    • ►November (51)
    • ►October (65)
    • ►September (52)
    • ►August (37)
    • ►July (70)
    • ►June (45)
    • ►May (61)
    • ►April (52)
    • ►March (66)
    • ►February (51)
    • ►January (62)
  • ►2009
    • ►September (55)
    • ►August (60)
    • ►July (51)
    • ►June (32)
    • ►May (87)
    • ►April (56)
    • ►March (57)
    • ►February (55)
    • ►January (62)

Archives Dropdown

© Copyright 2026 Montana Law Week. All Rights Reserved.

Website, hosting, and design provided by JHW Development