ZONING: Large-scale water bottling plant properly held to be valid nonconforming use under agriculture zoning regulations… Allison affirmed. [Read more…]
Insurance, defend/indemnify State for Libby asbestos
INSURANCE: Insurer correctly held to have breached duty to defend State for injury/death claims resulting from Libby asbestos… rulings that led to $97,833,193.93 judgment against insurer upheld except as to qualifying “occurrences” and coverage for claimants exposed to asbestos prior to policy period… Holly Brown affirmed, reversed. [Read more…]
Special Use Permit, Board of Adjustment appeal
SPECIAL USE PERMIT: 2015 statute granted Commissioners discretion in reviewing BOA determination but abuse of discretion standard of review applies… Commissioners abused discretion by re-weighing the evidence and modifying, reversing, or remanding BOA’s conditions… Manley. [Read more…]
Class action, Libby asbestos, “local controversy”
CLASS ACTION: Libby asbestos class action properly remanded to State Court based on “local controversy” exception to Class Action Fairness Act jurisdiction… Morris affirmed (memorandum). [Read more…]
Railroad strict liability
RAILROAD LIABILITY: BNSF strictly liable for abnormally dangerous activity vis-à-vis hauling amphibole asbestos in Libby… evidence of Grace’s conduct admissible for background and context but not to negate liability… Eddy. [Read more…]
Lead case against Grace’s comp insurer pre-trial rulings
LEAD CASE AGAINST GRACE’S COMP INSURER: Fact issues preclude summary judgment as to when Plaintiff knew he had ARD. . . MCC owed a duty of care to warn Zonolite and Grace of the hidden hazard of asbestos exposure, but fact issues exist as to whether it breached this duty to Plaintiff. . . Plaintiff who filed no comp claim has no common law insurance bad faith claim against MCC. . . MCC’s non-party (State, Grace) defenses precluded. . . other in limine rulings. . . Eddy. [Read more…]
$8,810,785 settlements with State
SETTLEMENT: $7,310,785.42 to 336 MHSL Libby Mine asbestos Claimants against State with contingent $2,030,936.19 dependent on result of litigation between State and its insurer. . . $1,250,000 to 49 KS Libby Mine Claimants with contingent $400,000. . . $250,000 for individual claimant with no insurer contingency. . . 33% and 33-1/3% contingent attorney fees approved. . . Eddy. [Read more…]
Request for additional depositions
BNSF’s request for leave to take additional depositions denied. . . Eddy. [Read more…]
Insurance, duty to defend State, Libby asbestos claims
INSURANCE: Insurer of State against Libby asbestos claims 7/73-7/75 breached duty to defend, liable for all defense costs incurred after 7/05, amounts of completed settlements as of date each was approved, pre-judgment interest on those amounts, attorney fees/costs incurred by State in this dec action. . . H. Brown. [Read more…]
Restoration damages, CERCLA preemption
RESTORATION DAMAGES: Bidegaray’s order denying summary judgment for ARCO on Property Owners’ restoration damages claim related to the Anaconda Smelter Superfund site as barred by CERCLA and granting summary judgment for Property Owners on ARCO’s CERCLA preemption defenses affirmed on petition for supervisory control… opinion & order. [Read more…]