CONFRONTATION: Wife’s testimony at order of protection hearing hearsay, pro se husband had opportunity to cross-examine but did not have same motive as in assault with weapon case, reading transcript to jury not harmless, conviction reversed… Langton reversed. [Read more…]
Archives for July 2015
Sexual assault, uncharged prior, sentencing
SEXUAL ASSAULT: Uncharged sexual assault properly admitted to show timeline of report of charged assault… evidence suggesting physical abuse by husband of one alleged victim years after alleged sexual assault properly excluded… written/oral sentencing inconsistencies remanded for correction… Boucher affirmed, reversed. [Read more…]
Supervisory control, medical/psychological records
SUPERVISORY CONTROL of Boucher granted ordering in camera review of medical/psychological records of minor with Williams Syndrome over objection from SIWC Defendant that review not necessary and Boucher’s position that he is not a psychologist or psychiatrist and has limited time for review… State has standing to petition on behalf of alleged victim… order. [Read more…]
Attempted deliberate homicide, victim interview
ATTEMPTED DELIBERATE HOMICIDE: Defendant properly precluded from playing tape of police interview of alleged victim, transcript was sufficient for impeachment… jury properly instructed on mental disease/defect… convictions affirmed… J. Brown affirmed (IOR I-3(d)). [Read more…]
Youth, “new” adult probation conditions
YOUTH: “New” standard adult probation conditions which were not set forth in Youth Court disposition or transfer order improperly imposed upon transfer to District Court, but 17 adult conditions properly imposed following revocation hearing based on termination from sex treatment, a condition of underlying disposition… Christopher affirmed (other grounds). [Read more…]
$126,000 verdict, cafe icy stairs slip & fall
VERDICT: $126,000, cafe icy stairs slip & fall, summary judgment liability, arm/hip/tailbone. [Read more…]
Settlements
Plan I
Joni McNeil, multiple, 5/11, $30,000, medical reserved, Charles McNeil [Read more…]
Lending breach, $52,037,593 verdict, TARP
LENDING BREACH: Montana law improperly applied over Michigan contract provision… under Michigan law constructive fraud, prospective economic advantage, and deceit would not have been permitted to go to jury as stand-alone tort, only remaining claims are contractual in nature, do not provide basis for punitives… improper evidence of failure to use TARP money for borrower irrelevant, prejudicial, could have influenced jury… $52,037,593 verdict for start-up international office products facility based in Butte that failed when accounts were swept reversed, remanded for new trial on contract claims… punitives cap vis-à-vis $10.5 million award not addressed… Krueger affirmed, reversed. [Read more…]
Probate, mineral interests, 14 years after death
PROBATE 14 years after death to confirm title to mineral interests per 1997 will not barred by general 3-year bar… undue influence, testamentary capacity properly rejected on summary judgment… Ortley affirmed. [Read more…]
Homeowners association, trail construction, fees
HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION: Covenants properly interpreted to require special assessment rather than maintenance funds for new trail construction… Association properly awarded fees/costs on counterclaim for unpaid dues & assessments… homeowner improperly awarded reciprocal fees/costs, properly denied fees/costs under UDJA… J. Brown affirmed, reversed. [Read more…]