ADMINISTRATIVE LAW: Plaintiffs may challenge constitutionality of statute authorizing DEQ permit only after completing Board of Environmental Review appeal… Ohman affirmed. [Read more…]
310 permit, pond along Flathead River
310 PERMIT to purportedly construct a berm to protect pole barn when water in pond along Flathead River rises properly denied… Eddy affirmed. [Read more…]
Environment, clean & healthful = stable climate system
ENVIRONMENT: Constitution’s clean & healthful environment properly found to include stable climate system, invalidates MEPA review limitation… 16 children had standing to bring challenge… psychiatric exams of 8 children properly denied… Seeley affirmed. [Read more…]
Opencut mining, preliminary injunction
OPENCUT MINING: Title 27 preliminary injunction provisions improperly applied to mining challenge when Plaintiff had remedy for similar relief in pending Title 75 action challenging environmental review… Larson reversed. [Read more…]
Stay pending appeal, greenhouse gas/climate rulings
STAY PENDING APPEAL denied as to Seeley’s denial of stay from her rulings in favor of youths requiring State agencies to consider greenhouse gas emissions and climate impacts in MEPA analyses… order. [Read more…]
Mining permit, neighbors’ objection to stone quarry
MINING PERMIT: Neighbors’ objection to stone quarry permit properly rejected… Wilson affirmed. [Read more…]
Breach of forbearance, $34,286,950 supersedeas bond
BREACH OF FORBEARANCE: Judgment for $26,374,576.13 with 10% post-judgment interest under 2005 statute for breach of bank’s Forbearance Agreement with office products entity reaffirmed… appeal bond set at 130% of amount of Judgment for appeal through Montana Supreme Court (not beyond)… Dayton. [Read more…]
Breach of forbearance, $7,535,593 fees, $8,067,406 interest
BREACH OF FORBEARANCE: $7,535,593.18 attorney fees, $8,067,405.60 prejudgment interest, $176,063.19 costs awarded on previous $10,595,414.16 judgment for breach of bank’s Forbearance Agreement with office products entity, applying Montana reciprocity law for fees (with 40% contingency), Michigan law for interest, Montana law for costs, plus post-judgment interest at 10% per 2005 statute… Dayton. [Read more…]
Mine trespass, no valuable mineral deposits, no trespass
MINE TRESPASS: Because there were no valuable mineral deposits on Subject Claims, Wheelis improperly granted summary judgment for trespass claimants in 2013 (summary judgment was basis of damages-only ruling by Cuffe in 2018 trial which resulted in $3,325,000 verdict for owners of unpatented mining claims crossed by tunnel constructed to access patented claims of proposed Montanore mine)… Wheelis/Cuffe reversed. [Read more…]
$10,595,514 judgment, breach of forbearance agreement
BENCH JUDGMENT: $10,595,514.16 seized from start-up international office products facility causing its demise awarded as damages for breach of bank’s forbearance agreement… trial on contract damages under Michigan law on remand from reversal of $52,037,593 verdict which was improperly based on Montana law… Dayton. [Read more…]