INSURANCE: Insurer’s consideration of $40,000 med-pay as element of $192,615 MVA liability settlement reasonable as matter of law… no justiciable controversy that would support bad faith, class action… Haddon. [Read more…]
Insurance, church sex abuse, policy period
INSURANCE: No duty to defend/indemnity Diocese for alleged sex abuse which occurred prior to 1/1/77 under occurrence-based certificates or that occurred before 7/1/90 under claims-made certificates… unreasonable to require coverage for events that [Read more…]
Class action, Allstate CCPR
CLASS ACTION properly certified as to Allstate’s CCPR program following remand, but class-wide punitives inappropriate, remanded for class trial to determine if application of CCPR to class violated UTPA, if so to determine if Allstate should be [Read more…]
Sanctions, $35,841 fees, $32,909 fine, Rule 11
SANCTIONS: $35,841 attorney fees, $32,909 fine as if Court were law firm, properly imposed on attorney under Rule 11 for improper filings and attacks on insurer and counsel… Haynes affirmed. [Read more…]
Insurance, “junk health insurance,” fraud/RICO
INSURANCE: Dissolved Tennessee “junk health insurance” entity has capacity to be sued on theory of successor liability… fraud, constructive fraud, RICO claims sufficiently pled, punitives may be appropriate… most claims not time-barred… personal [Read more…]
Insurance, “tough love” school suicide
INSURANCE: CGL/excess insurers had duty to defend “tough love” school against teen suicide claims, liable for $3 million consent judgment plus $568,767 interest… $1,188,399 fees improperly awarded based on judgment and contingency in underlying case, remanded for recalculation on [Read more…]
Negligence, CO poisoning, defense verdict
NEGLIGENCE: Equal protection challenge to §39-71-413(2) comp exclusivity vicarious liability shield as to corporations and related instructions mooted by defense verdict as to owner/managers in CO poisoning case… evidence of cause of [Read more…]
Insurance, family member exclusion
INSURANCE: Driver killed in single-vehicle crash properly excluded under family member exclusion, insurer had no duty to defend estate, not liable for $3 million default judgment against estate… negligence, common law bad faith, fraud, negligent misrepresentation claims time- [Read more…]
Attorney fees, wrongful premium retention
ATTORNEY FEES in wrongful premium retention class action settlement reduced from $1,650,408 to $692,881 in light of further analysis of settlement value, not on basis of 60(b)(2) new evidence, but on basis of 60(b)(6) extraordinary circumstances and agreement that fees shall be determined by the Court… Molloy. [Read more…]
Sanctions, Rule 11, $35,841 fees, like amount fine
SANCTIONS: Not feasible for attorney to take Law School research/writing class but feasible to receive instruction from legal writing director… expert provided unilluminating apples-to-oranges analysis as to insurer’s reasonable Rule 11 hours… insurer’s use of 2 attorneys from different firms in underlying litigation and sanctions [Read more…]