INSURANCE: Coverage of breast cancer med-mal claim precluded by failure to timely notify insurer as to one policy and prior-knowledge exception as to other… Cavan/Watters affirmed (memorandum). [Read more…]
Smelter contamination, landowners’ restoration damages
SMELTER CONTAMINATION: Landowners’ claim for restoration damages relating to discharge of arsenic and lead remanded to District Court following US Supreme Court’s allowing claim with EPA approval… order. [Read more…]
Legal malpractice, failure to disclose expert
LEGAL MALPRACTICE claims properly dismissed for untimely failure to disclose expert… R. McElyea affirmed (IOR I-3(c)). [Read more…]
Restoration damages, landowners’ smelter contamination
RESTORATION DAMAGES: Landowners affected by smelter contamination are “potentially responsible parties” under CERCLA, need EPA approval to take independent remedial action… Montana Supreme Court affirmed as to jurisdiction, reversed on the merits. [Read more…]
Prisoners, petition to mandate jail reduction for COVID
PRISONERS: Petition to mandate immediate reduction of population of jails and prisons because of COVID-19 pandemic denied… order. [Read more…]
Insurance, Iowa UM/UIM reinsurer, shooting death
INSURANCE: Contract and declaratory claims against Iowa UM/UIM reinsurer relating to shooting death in Montana of South Dakota resident driving vehicle with business policy and shooter driving uninsured or underinsured vehicle dismissed for lack of personal jurisdiction… Cavan. [Read more…]
Medical examiners, licensure negligence/nuisance
MEDICAL EXAMINERS: Supervisory control denied as to Judge Krueger’s denial of Rule 12(b)(6) motion for dismissal from action alleging negligence and private & public nuisance for failing to deny or terminate license of psychiatrist who allegedly prescribed improper meds… public duty/quasi-judicial immunity arguments more properly first developed and argued below… order. [Read more…]
Class certification, student loan claims
CLASS CERTIFICATION: 2 classes asserting claims related to UM student loan disbursements improperly certified, 1 class properly certified… Wheelis reversed, affirmed. [Read more…]
Insurance, $10 million consent judgment reasonableness
INSURANCE: $10 million consent judgment in favor of ranchers and against CPA firm improperly given presumption of reasonableness where insurer was providing a defense and had not “abandoned” the insured… remanded for separate breach of contract or UTPA claims with insured having to prove all elements including damages… Eddy reversed. [Read more…]
Legal malpractice insurance, rescission, innocent partner
LEGAL MALPRACTICE INSURANCE improperly rescinded, voided ab initio, as to innocent partner of partner who stole from clients. . . ruling upholding rescission understandable as based on erroneous precedent that insurers had statutory right to rescission without equitable considerations. . . stare decisis does not require perpetuation of incorrect precedent. . . 3rd-party claims properly barred because they were lodged after policy canceled or under criminal exclusion. . . Haynes reversed, affirmed. [Read more…]