RESTORATION DAMAGES: Bidegaray’s order denying summary judgment for ARCO on Property Owners’ restoration damages claim related to the Anaconda Smelter Superfund site as barred by CERCLA and granting summary judgment for Property Owners on ARCO’s CERCLA preemption defenses affirmed on petition for supervisory control… opinion & order. [Read more…]
Insurance, attorney fees, UIM excess verdict
INSURANCE: When UIM insured is compelled to pursue litigation and a jury awards more than settlement offer, insurer must pay attorney fees… Plaintiff was compelled to sue, jury returned $450,000 verdict, insurer offered $77,500… Menahan reversed. [Read more…]
Jurisdiction, restoration plan “reactive” challenge
JURISDICTION declined over “reactive” request that environmental restoration plan proposed by landowners in pending State Court action be declared prohibited by CERCLA… Lynch/Morris. [Read more…]
Medical malpractice rulings, rebuttal disclosures
MEDICAL MALPRACTICE: Rulings on expert/rebuttal disclosures in heart attack case against hospital involving issues of oxygen saturation, unnamed hospital doctors… fact issues as to breach of standard of care precludes summary judgment for Plaintiff on liability… hospital’s motion for summary judgment based on “judicial admissions” by Plaintiff’s counsel rejected… J. Brown. [Read more…]
Attorney disqualification, prospective client
ATTORNEY DISQUALIFICATION: Rifle manufacturer’s national counsel improperly used fact that Plaintiffs had been turned down by local counsel to intimidate and create impression they had bad case… national and local firms properly disqualified… Salvagni affirmed. [Read more…]
Insurance, gasoline tanker spill, $13,066,474
INSURANCE: Ambiguous “general aggregate” limit in excess liability policy construed to provide additional $4 million for Homeowners for damages from gasoline tanker spill, Homeowners properly awarded attorney fees for insurer’s breach of duty to indemnify to proper limits… insurer did not breach duty to defend by withdrawing from defense and subsequently reinitiating defense (applying Independent Milk to breach of assumed duty to defend), not liable for $13,066,474 stipulated judgment entered 8 months later… McLean affirmed, reversed. [Read more…]
$3,146,185 fees, $29M ESOP stipulated judgment
ATTORNEY FEES: $3,146,185 fees, $89,153 costs awarded in $29 million settlement/stipulated judgment and assignment of rights by grocery chain executives to 35 ESOP participants… $35,816,986 total judgment with $6,816,986 prejudgment interest… appeal bond waived for $26 billion insurer… Townsend. [Read more…]
Contamination, smelter, soil, summary judgment
ENVIRONMENTAL CONTAMINATION: Smelter soil contamination summary judgment rulings affirmed, reversed… Newman affirmed, reversed. [Read more…]
Insurance, notice-prejudice, 3rd-party
INSURANCE: Insurer who does not receive timely notice pursuant to policy terms must demonstrate prejudice to avoid defense/indemnification… notice-prejudice rule in 3rd-party case… certified question by 9th Circuit. [Read more…]
City negligence, public duty, skateboard death
CITY NEGLIGENCE: Public duty doctrine improperly applied to bar claims against City in skateboarder death on steep hill on subdivision-owned but City-approved walking path… Curtis/Allison reversed. [Read more…]