VERDICT: $3,325,000 for trespass to owners of unpatented mining claims crossed by tunnel constructed to access patented claims of proposed Montanore mine. [Read more…]
Endangered species, irrigation dam bypass v. removal
ENDANGERED SPECIES: Challenges to irrigation dam bypass (as opposed to dam removal and installation of large pumps) to accommodate pallid sturgeon rejected on summary judgment on remand from 9th Circuit reversal of preliminary injunction. . . Morris. [Read more…]
Environment, Yellowstone dam preliminary injunction
ENVIRONMENT: Preliminary injunction against Yellowstone River dam vacated for failure to show irreparable harm to sturgeon. . . Morris reversed (unpublished). [Read more…]
Federal mining condemnation, jury footnote
MINING CONDEMNATION: Footnote addressing jury issue added to opinion holding that stay of federal mining condemnation should have been granted pending parallel State Court action… rehearing denied… order. [Read more…]
Stay, federal v. state mining condemnation
STAY of federal mining condemnation should have been granted pending parallel State Court action… Christensen reversed. [Read more…]
Illegal aliens/attorney fees, LR 121
ILLEGAL ALIENS/ATTORNEY FEES: Immigrant association which includes Mexicans with permanent residence has standing to challenge LR 121 which requires denial of state-funded services to “illegal aliens”… LR 121 properly found preempted by federal law… $127,660.80 attorney fees improperly awarded under erroneous interpretation of Svee… Sherlock affirmed, reversed. [Read more…]
Public road, Modesty Creek rehearing denied
PUBLIC ROAD: Rehearing denied as to Modesty Creek Road rulings… order. [Read more…]
Public road, statutory, prescriptive, reverse adverse
PUBLIC ROAD: Lower branch properly found to have been statutorily created… any public prescriptive easement to upper branch extinguished by reverse adverse possession… Krueger affirmed, reversed. [Read more…]
Robbery, pretrial punishment, “criminal purpose”
ROBBERY: Plain error review declined for claims of pretrial punishment by being held in solitary & restraints for 5 months prior to sentencing, allegedly sanctioned by Judge at transport hearing while Defendant was at MSH for fitness evaluation… “criminal purpose” of robbery not completed when shoplifted goods were abandoned outside store after being confronted, ripened into felony robbery when he injured or threatened to injure pursuers… Defendant required to testify to lay foundation for justifiable force… Deschamps affirmed. [Read more…]
Lending breach, $52,037,593 verdict, TARP
LENDING BREACH: Montana law improperly applied over Michigan contract provision… under Michigan law constructive fraud, prospective economic advantage, and deceit would not have been permitted to go to jury as stand-alone tort, only remaining claims are contractual in nature, do not provide basis for punitives… improper evidence of failure to use TARP money for borrower irrelevant, prejudicial, could have influenced jury… $52,037,593 verdict for start-up international office products facility based in Butte that failed when accounts were swept reversed, remanded for new trial on contract claims… punitives cap vis-à-vis $10.5 million award not addressed… Krueger affirmed, reversed. [Read more…]